In today’s world of youth sports and competitions, the phrase “everyone gets a trophy” has sparked a heated debate. Some argue that rewarding every participant builds confidence and encourages teamwork, while others believe it takes away the value of hard work and true achievement.
According to the website aish.com, “Trophies were once rare things. Today, participation trophies and prizes are almost a given, as children are constantly assured that they are all winners.”
Ms. Kristy McGoldrick, a math teacher at Carolina Forest High School, commented, “I absolutely despise participation trophies. I always teach my kids to strive for the best and never settle for something, and that’s what the trophies are doing. Symbolizing that it is okay to not try for first place because they are going to get a trophy anyway.”
As a child, I personally never liked it when that happened because it diminished the glow of my win, and made the losers feel even worse because they are getting a pity prize.
Leyla Hoagland, a senior at CFHS, and I are both part of the Teacher Cadet class. During this class, we discussed a self-esteem unit.
Hoagland stated, “I do believe that not everyone deserves a trophy because that can bring down, not just the winner’s self-esteem, but the losers because they might feel bad about stealing the spotlight.”
However, many people do think that everyone getting a trophy is actually beneficial to a child’s self-esteem and makes them want to get better so they can work up to the “winner’s” trophy.
According to psychologytoday.com, “They [trophies] have been used for decades to encourage and reward children for participating in fun and healthy activities, like sports. They recognize effort, which children can modulate, rather than intrinsic ability and outcomes, which are dependent on many things that children cannot control.”
Yamilet Diego, a sophomore, stated, “I think that everyone deserves a trophy because when I was younger, I used to play soccer, and when I would lose, I would look forward to the participation trophy. It kept me motivated.”
Ultimately, the debate over participation trophies challenges us to decide whether recognition should celebrate effort, achievement, or a balance of both.
(Photo Credit: Google)
